Pakistani Librarianship During the 1990s: A literature Review

Abstract

This essay describes the current status of library and information services in Pakistan. Specific consideration is given to the National Library, as well as to academic, public, special, children’s, and school libraries. A picture of LIS education, information technology in libraries, and other professional issues is also painted. The essay reviews library literature published in and outside Pakistan during 1990–96. The scope of the study includes journal articles, books, theses, seminar proceedings, and reports published either in English or in Urdu. Sixty–three items are reviewed. The literature referred to constitutes a comprehensive bibliography of important aspects of Pakistani librarianship.

Introduction

The Islamic Republic of Pakistan occupies 796,095 sq. km. and is bounded by India, Afghanistan, China, Iran, and the Arabian Sea. It was constituted on 14 August 1947 and consisted of the following territories of British India: Baluchistan, East Bengal, North–West Frontier, West Punjab, and Sind. In 1971 East Bengal declared itself an independent state, Bangladesh. Now the country consists of four provinces and a centrally administered Federal and Tribal Area. Islamabad is the capital city. With a density of 149.6 persons per sq. km., the population is estimated to be 131.5 million. The system of government is parliamentary. Urdu is the national language, although 48% of the population speak Punjabi. English is used in business, higher education, and central government. Per capita GNP is US$410. In 19914, 532 newspapers and other periodicals were published in the country. Adult literacy was 34% in 1992. Figures for 1991–92 show that there were 119,812 primary, 8,914 middle, and 10,061 secondary schools, 477 vocational institutions, 742 colleges, and 22 universities. The total student enrollment in all educational institutions is about 18 million. (The Statesman’s Yearbook 1995–96.)

According to Anis (1990) there are 6,034 libraries in Pakistan, of which 4,373 are box libraries. The box libraries were established in villages during the 1980s under a program sponsored by the Ministry of Local Government and Rural Development in cooperation with the Asia Foundation of Pakistan (Anis 1987). The total collection in all types of libraries is 13.35 million volumes. Punjab province alone holds 40% of the books. Three cities, Karachi, Lahore, and Rawalpindi–Islamabad, have more than 50% of the books in the country. A directory of libraries compiled by the Pakistan Library Association lists 1,767 college, public, school, national, special, and university libraries in Pakistan (Khubaib 1996).

National Library

When was the National Library of Pakistan founded? Pakistani writers give four different dates. After a detailed discussion, Anwar (1993) concludes that in 1949 the Pakistan Government set up the Directorate of Archives and Libraries. The National Library was made a branch of the Directorate. According to Akhtar (1992), in 1954 the Liaquat Memorial Library in Karachi was amalgamated with the National Library and renamed the Liaquat National Library. Later, in 1968, the library was declared a legal depository under the Copyright Law of 1962. After the capital was shifted from Karachi to Islamabad, it was decided to establish the National Library of Pakistan in the new capital, and the Liaquat National Library was renamed Liaquat Memorial Library. Construction work for the new building started in 1982 and was completed in 1988 at a cost of Rs. 130.322 million. The building, centrally air–conditioned and heated, provides a covered area of 168,844 sq. ft.

Over the past few years about 90,000 volumes have been acquired through purchases, gifts, exchanges, and legal deposit. These include 522 manuscripts and over 9,400 rare books in Urdu, Arabic, Persian, and other languages. UNESCO has approved the National Library of Pakistan as a depository of its publications. The Delivery of Books and Newspapers Branch has, since its establishment in 1969, received over 25,000 Pakistani publications. It also receives regularly about 650 periodicals and eighty newspapers. Four large reading halls with seating capacity for 500 persons have been provided for the study of European languages and literature, Oriental languages and literature, the Pakistan collection, and newspapers and periodicals. A separate reading room has been established for the study of manuscripts and rare books. The National Library compiles the annual volumes of the Pakistan National Bibliography and issues a monthly Accessions List–Pakistan based upon the deposit of publications under the Copyright Law (Akhtar 1993). The NLP, after its designation as ISBN Agency for Pakistan in 1984, has registered 229 publishers and allotted an ISBN to 4,784 books up to the end of February 1991 (Riazuddin 1993). The new National Library was formally inaugurated on 24 August 1993 at Islamabad by Mr. Moeenuddin Qureshi, the Prime Minister of Pakistan.

Archival materials are maintained at the federal and provincial government levels. The National Archives of Pakistan also holds private collections and will house the Freedom Movement Archives, some 100,000 documents pertaining to the All–India Muslim League. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs maintains its archives independently (Anis 1993).

Academic Libraries

The ten universities existing in 1981 grew to twenty–three by 1989. As far as the total collection of the university libraries is concerned, Anis (1993) estimates it as 2,900,000 volumes, more than a fifth of all of the books in Pakistani libraries, while Fazil (1995 & 1996) counts it as 3,296,517 volumes of books, 4,505 periodical titles, 32,360 manuscripts, and 23,182 items in microform. University libraries maintain this material to meet the study and research requirements of 56,402 students and 8,708 faculty members and research scholars. In 1994 there were fifty books per reader, compared with 112 books per student in the U.K. “Inadequacy of materials in Pakistani university libraries can further be elaborated by the fact that [the] total collection of all the twenty government–funded university libraries is one–third of the collections of a single library of Yale University in [the] USA, which alone contains as many as 9,937,751 volumes” (Fazil 1995). The ratio of professional to non-professional library staff ranges from 25:82 to 2:19. Based upon a financial survey of fourteen libraries (Fazil 1995), an average amount for each university library is hardly 3% of the over–all budget of the university. Moreover, reference, indexing, and abstracting services are almost non–existent. Even catalogues are not up to date.

According to a survey of fifteen university libraries conducted by Yaqub (1990), there are thirty–nine volumes per user. One university library has only 9,612 volumes in its collection. The maximum number of transactions in a university during a regular work–day is 403. This comes out to 0.06 transactions per user. Only twelve libraries have open stacks. According to Yaqub (1992), the financial position of university libraries is very poor. Except for Karachi University, the universities allocate less than 5% of their total budget for libraries. Qureshi (1990) points out that several university libraries in Pakistan have their own buildings, but the maintenance of these buildings has been neglected. In some buildings there is no proper arrangement for light and ventilation.

Punjab University, the oldest in the country, has thirty–eight libraries, including one central library which is the best repository of manuscripts in the country. Eighty–five professional librarians and 310 non–professionals manage a total of 913,504 volumes (Siddique 1994). The libraries of Pakistan’s 680 colleges hold more than 3,640,000 volumes (Anis 1993).

Public Libraries

According to Anis (1993), public libraries in Pakistan grew from just twenty–one in 1951 to more than 280 by 1989. The Punjab Public Library, Lahore (founded 1884), holds the country’s third–largest collection (215,000 volumes), with 1,200 manuscripts in Arabic, Gurmukhi, Persian, and Urdu. The Dayal Singh Trust Library, Lahore (founded 1908), holds 122,000 volumes. Others include the Liaquat Memorial Library, Karachi (1950; 120,000 volumes), and the Central Public Library, Bahawalpur (1948; 100,000 volumes). The Quaid–e–Azam Reference and Research Library opened to the public in Lahore’s beautiful gardens, Bagh–e–Jinnah, in 1984. Among the oldest libraries in the country are the Karachi Metropolitan City Library (founded in 1851 as the Frere Hall Library; 43,300 volumes) and Sandeman Public Library, Quetta (1856; 16,700 volumes). Khubaib (1996) gives information about 301 public libraries. Sadiq (1993) writes that there are 150 public libraries in Pakistan, but in a strict sense no public library actually exists. The largest cities do possess library facilities, but the 80% of the population living in rural areas are not in a position to have access to these facilities. The public libraries are largely maintained by local government. Taj (1990) reports a survey of eighty–two out of 238 public libraries in the province of Punjab. Only sixteen have professional staff. The Punjab Government allowed all local bodies to spend 1% of their total revenues on the development of libraries, but according to the survey the actual allocation is less than 0.4%.

In the 1990s, two bookmobile units organized by the Punjab Library Foundation have been started at Lahore and Gujranwala Divisions (Jalal 1993). Six American Centre Libraries in the country provide SDI and Article Alert services. For this purpose a profile of interests of active library users is maintained on computer. Table of Contents service is also provided. In this service photocopies of contents pages are sent to the readers by mail, and articles in full text are supplied on request. United States Information Service (USIS) Libraries also donate books to other institutions (Siddiqui 1990). The British Council Libraries in Pakistan, established in 1948, were the first to establish a network of libraries with an effective union catalogue and an inter–library loan system. The libraries provide MEDLINE searching service through a CD–ROM database. In June 1995 the Council Libraries network was connected on electronic mail (Javed 1995).

Children’s and School Libraries

Libraries in schools, Nasim (1991) says, are in poor condition. Unfortunately, whenever library surveys were conducted school libraries were ignored. Many library directories were published but none of them included school libraries. Some research reports were also submitted in the form of library surveys, but they excluded school libraries. Hanif (1990) writes that there are about 84,000 primary schools in Pakistan and they are spread throughout the country. To be able to establish libraries in every nook and corner of the country, there is no better place than the primary schools. They are available even in small villages. These libraries can create a reading public which can go into the millions. The enrollment in primary schools is about eight million. If such a huge number is made book–minded it can completely change the outlook of the country.

Nasim (1990) reports the findings of a survey of forty-three libraries offering services to children in ten cities of Pakistan. The survey proved that library services for children are not satisfactory. The Punjab Provincial Government has, however, taken some steps in this field. The inauguration of a “Children’s Library Complex” in 1988 by the Punjab Chief Minister is a noteworthy event in the history of children’s librarianship in Pakistan. “Factors affecting school library development in Pakistan are lack of library awareness, planning, funds, space, professional staff, resources, services, [and] reading habits; and ignorance of modern technology. If we remove these we can build a better network of school library services in Pakistan” (Nasim 1991).

Special Libraries

Anis (1993) estimates that 330 special libraries in Pakistan hold some 2,500,000 volumes. Two of the oldest libraries are the Punjab Civil Secretariat Library, Lahore (founded in 1885; 60,000 volumes), and the Punjab Textbook Board Library, Lahore (1892; 32,000 volumes). Khubaib (1996) lists 423 special libraries.

The history of medical libraries in Pakistan goes as [far] back as... 1860 when the first Medical College was established in this part of the subcontinent. At the time of the establishment of Pakistan there were two colleges, King Edward Medical College at Lahore and the Dow Medical College at Karachi. With the passing of ... time the number of medical colleges has risen to seventeen. Apart from this, there is Agha Khan Medical University and other specialized medical institutions, as well as hospitals which have attached libraries. In the absence of authentic statistics, their exact number and collection .. . [are] not known, but it is estimated that the number of medical libraries in Pakistan is around fifty. The recent development in medical libraries is the computerization of Agha Khan University Library and the Library of the College of Physicians and Surgeons, Karachi. The College of Physicians and Surgeons Library has been designated as the National Focal Point for MEDLINE and has acquired the CD–ROM disks from 1980 onwards. (Hanif 1991)

Qureshi (1990a) writes that medical librarianship is a new profession in Pakistan. For a long time the librarians working in medical libraries felt the need of a platform where they could gather and discuss issues of mutual interest. As a result, the Pakistan Medical Library Association (PMLA) came into being in 1987. Qureshi concludes his article by saying that the situation of medical college libraries in Pakistan is not very encouraging. Very few medical colleges have good libraries. Because of the lack of adequate resources, and some other factors, the Pakistan medical college libraries can not be compared with those of the developed countries.

Agriculture plays a vital role in Pakistan’s economy. It employs more than half of the population and contributes 24% of the GDP. Javed and Meer (1990) surveyed fifty–one libraries in the field of agriculture. There are mainly two types of agricultural libraries in Pakistan: academic and research. Academic libraries belong to the institutions offering formal degree programmes in the field of agriculture, such as the universities of agriculture at Faisalabad, Tandojam, and Peshawar. Research libraries belong to the institutes and centres conducting scientific research in different areas of agriculture, such as the National Agricultural Research Centre (NARC), Islamabad, and Ayub Agricultural Research Centre, Faisalabad.

Bushra (1990) describes the activities of the Lahore Business and Economics Libraries Network (LABELNET), which is aimed at facilitating resource sharing among the libraries in the areas of business and public administration and other related fields. The project started in 1986, and is jointly sponsored by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC), Canada, and the Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS). The publications of the project include The Union List of Serials of Business and Economics Libraries in Lahore (Lahore: LABELNET, 1990) and A Union Catalog of Publications on Pakistan’s Business and Economy in LABELNET Libraries (Lahore: LABELNET, 1990). The project has introduced the use of Micro CDS/ISIS software into libraries in Lahore. Nuzhat (1990) describes the activities of the National Documentation Centre Library and Information Network (NADLIN) in the field of water resources. It is funded by USAID. The other NADLIN collaborators include eight institutions working in the field of water management.

Library and Information Science Education

LIS education has been the most popular subject in library literature published during 1990s. Discussing the development of library education in the Indian sub-continent, Anis (1992) writes,

The coming of American librarians in British India eventually resulted in the introduction of library science instruction at university level. In 1915, Asa Don Dickinson (1876–1960) came to Lahore upon his appointment as University Librarian to organize the Punjab University Library and also to teach modern library methods. Dickinson’s certificate course of one academic year started in the autumn of 1915 in the University Library. This was a post–graduate day–time course, but undergraduate working librarians including non–matriculates were also admitted to it. It is interesting to note here that this was the first university–based course in the then British empire, as the London University had not established its Diploma course by that time. The course remained suspended for two years after Dickinson’s departure in 1916. Revived in 1918, the course was converted to a post–graduate course in 1928. The study of German or French was made compulsory in 1936.

Sajjad (1993) adds that the course was again suspended during 1945–49 because of the chaotic conditions of the pre– and post–independence era. In 1959, the name of this post–graduate certificate was changed to “diploma.” In the meantime, the University of Karachi had introduced its part–time study programme in 1956. After having instituted the first post–graduate diploma programme, the University of Karachi was quick enough to introduce a master’s degree programme in 1962. Afterwards the other universities started their diploma and master’s programmes. Fazil (1994) gives these details of the programmes:

 CertificateDiplomaM.A.M.Phil.Ph.D.
Karachi University1956196219851967
Punjab University191519591959
Peshawar University19621962
Sind University197019701983
Baluchistan University19781978
Bahawalpur University198319831986

According to Mangla (1994), candidates having a good bachelor’s degree are generally able to secure admission to the diploma course. For admission to the master’s degree course, in addition to possessing the post–graduate diploma, a candidate is usually required to have experience in a library of good standing. It is estimated that the annual enrollment for the diploma and master’s degree courses in six library schools is 260 and 140 respectively. On the basis of annual enrollments, the total number of graduates from these library schools through 1992 would be about 4,100 and 1,650, respectively. Hamid (1992) gives the total number of diploma and master’s degree holders as 3,304 and 2,349, respectively.

In the beginning, most of the teachers in departments of library science in the universities of the country were part–time, and were drawn from among the top librarians. Out of thirty–three teachers, twenty–two were part–time during the academic year 1965–66 (Sadiq 1994). According to Sajjad (1994) there are forty–four faculty positions in six library schools, of which thirty–four are filled.

The University Grants Commission revised the LIS curriculum in 1991 and 1995. In designing a new curriculum the following factors were given special consideration: current trends in library education internationally; changing needs of libraries and information services in Pakistan; and financial implications of the revision. The revised curriculum includes such new courses as Library Automation; Information Storage and Retrieval; Networking and Resource Sharing; Communication and A.V. Media Librarianship; Management Information System; and Marketing of Information Services. The Curriculum Revision Committee also made a number of recommendations to facilitate the implementation of the proposed curricula. These include organization of training laboratories provided with adequate information technology equipment at all library schools; development and strengthening of the libraries attached to the departments; replacement of the chalk and talk method by other modern teaching technology supported with audio–visual and practical training aids; and strengthening the staff development programmes through organization of courses and workshops on topics of interest (Haider 1995).

Allama Iqbal Open University started LIS education through distance learning in 1988. The Certificate in Librarianship consists of two courses, Organizing Library Resources and Library Services. To introduce the Bachelor in Library and Information Sciences (BLIS), two more courses were started in 1990. These are History of Libraries with Reference to Pakistan and Classification and Cataloguing. The following are the enrollment figures from the Spring 1988 to Autumn 1994 semesters:

Course CodeCourse TitleEnrollment
422Organizing Library Resources5,182
423Library Services4,539
466History of Libraries with Reference to Pakistan1,914
467Classification and Cataloguing996

The University is planning to introduce a master's programme in the near future (Basharat 1994 and Niaz 1995).

In the 1970s, the Pakistan Library Association proposed introducing library science as an optional subject at the intermediate level. College librarians actively supported this idea. The Boards of Intermediate and Secondary Education of Karachi and Hyderabad approved the introduction of library science courses at the intermediate level in their respective areas of jurisdiction. The Boards of Sargodha and the Centrally Administered Area awarded similar approval at a later stage (Anis 1992). During 1990–91 all boards in Punjab province approved the subject at the intermediate level, and it is being taught at various colleges (Nazir 1992). The subject has been taught at the B.A. level in one college in Karachi since 1982 (Anis 1992). Punjab University approved an LIS curriculum at the bachelor’s level in 1995.

Siddique (1992) reviews the research conducted by the students of six library schools. Four hundred twenty–seven master’s theses were produced until 1989, for an annual output of 18.56. The compilation of bibliographies, union catalogues, or indexes was the most popular work, accounting for 26.7% of the theses. Fifty–five percent of the theses were written in English, and 45% in Urdu.

Information Technology in Libraries

Because of its efficiency, marvelous performance, and ability to handle a large quantity of documents, the computer is becoming popular in librarianship and information services. In Pakistan, library automation was introduced in the 1980s, and a number of libraries were computerized in or after 1987 (Khalid 1995). Bushra (1993) describes the problems faced by Pakistani libraries in automating their procedures. She mentions computer illiteracy, improper planning, unavailability of library software, retrospective conversion, lack of standardization and quality control, bureaucratic set–up, and lack of technical expertise. Sadiq (1994) gives a list of twenty–three libraries which are in the process of being computerized, and tells what software they are using. Maqsood (1993) reports on a survey of ninety–five libraries which are using computers in the cities of Islamabad and Rawalpindi. Most of the libraries have IBM–compatible personal computers, and are concentrating on cataloguing and acquisitions. Only 39% of the institutions have staff trained in library automation. Discussing the myths and realities of library automation in Pakistan, Sajjad (1992) tries to remove the confusion about library automation in the minds of librarians. He says that a badly–managed library can not be improved with the help of computers; a computer can only retrieve information about documents, but does not provide access to those documents; library automation is not an objective in itself; merely buying a computer does not mean library automation; provision of the right hardware is only one of the many requisites for an automation project; system development is too costly to be affordable for our libraries; and training of personnel and retrospective conversion are important facets of library automation. Anwar (1992) discusses some critical issues in the use of information technology in Pakistani libraries. According to him, Pakistan spends only 0.2% of its GNP on R&D activities; foreign information resources and services are expensive; it is impossible for individual libraries to be self–sufficient in supplying information; National Information Centres should be set up; there should be coordination among libraries and information centres; a National Centre for Software Development and Training should be created; and appropriate manpower should be developed for library automation. According to Najaf (1995), most of the university libraries in Pakistan have not yet seriously considered the use of computers in library operations. Only a few university libraries now have computers. With the exception of three agricultural university libraries and two private university libraries, no other university library is using information technology. The major limiting factors for not introducing information technology in the university libraries of Pakistan appear to be lack of initiative and failure to realize the importance of information by the top management of the university; lack of proper finances; lack of trained manpower; and lack of information sensitivity.

Software used mostly for housekeeping routines in Pakistani libraries includes dBase, Foxpro, INMAGIC, CDS/ISIS, KITABDAR, and LAMP (Khalid 1995a). LAMP software, developed by the Netherlands Library Development Project (NLDP) with the collaboration of the Pakistan Library Association (PLA), is being used in more than fifty libraries, including six legislative libraries. The software can handle acquisitions, cataloguing, and the circulation of books and serials. An Urdu version of LAMP has also been prepared (Khalid 1996).

NLDP has played an important role in promoting information technology in Pakistan. The promotion activities include setting up five PLA computer training centres; inviting automation experts from abroad; sponsoring librarians to attend advanced courses abroad; supplying hardware to libraries and library schools; establishing information networks; developing software; carrying out retrospective conversion; developing a national database on CD–ROM; establishing the Library Automation Group (LAG); and including information technology components in the revised curriculum of library schools (Khalid 1996a). The PLA Computer Training Centre at Lahore started functioning on 2 November 1992. To run the Centre’s affairs a Managing Committee and a Program Committee have been set up. The training programme includes core and advanced courses (Bushra 1993a). Until January 1996, thirteen courses had been conducted at the Centre, with 259 persons attending. Consultancy services to libraries throughout the province have also been provided by the Centre (Khalid 1996b). Karachi Centre trained 126 librarians in library automation. This is 31% of the total number of librarians working in Karachi (Samdani 1995).

The Department of Library and Information Science at Punjab University has a computer laboratory with five personal computers. CD–ROM and e–mail are available. The departmental library has been automated using LAMP software (Khalid 1996c). In August 1989, the Directorate of Scientific Information (National Agricultural Research Centre) installed a CD–ROM unit along with the AGRICOLA database. This was the first entry of CD–ROM into Pakistani libraries or information centres. Now more than thirty–two institutions in Pakistan are using CD–ROM technology for searching international databases. Currently more than seventy databases are available on CD–ROM in different libraries. Most of these are in agriculture, biology, and medicine, but databases in other fields (such as education, economics, sociology, water resources, environment, fisheries, extension, library and information sciences, science, and technology) are also available. Encyclopedias, dictionaries, and computer programmes are also procured by some libraries for their reference sections (Shahnaz 1994). Shahnaz and Bhatti (1993) give a list of CD–ROM databases available in various libraries.

Library Profession

The Pakistan Library Association was established in 1957 in Karachi with the following aims and objectives:

  1. To establish a comprehensive library service throughout Pakistan;
  2. To promote study and research in library science, and the dissemination of information about current trends, theories, and practices in the field of librarianship;
  3. To improve the status and professional standing of library workers, and safeguard their interests; and
  4. For such other ends as will further the cause of libraries and librarians of Pakistan. (Umera)

It is governed by an Executive Council, and there are five branch councils, viz., Punjab; Baluchistan; (NWFP); Sind and Federal region, including Gilgit; and Azad Kashmir and Tribal Areas. The headquarters rotate among the branches. The PLA Journal was first published in 1962. Revived in 1968, it ceased publication after two or three issues. Eventually it was revived again, in August 1987 (Qureshi 1991). The PLA has twenty–one items on its publications list. The 15th PLA conference was held in 1994 at Lahore. During the 1990s, the Association arranged various seminars, workshops, and lectures. Library automation and new information technology were the major topics of all of the continuing education activities. The membership of the PLA exceeded 1,400 for the first time in 1994.

The most active professional association during the period has been the Punjab University Library Science Alumni Association (PULSAA). Revived in 1988, PULSAA has done a lot for the profession. Its outstanding activities during 1989–90 include the publication of PULSAA News; a number of short courses and seminars; a lecture on CD–ROM; and the establishment of a computer laboratory at the Department of Library Science, Punjab University (Mirza 1990). To celebrate seventy–five years of the department’s existence, in 1990, PULSAA launched a Diamond Jubilee programme. A three–day conference on “Library Education in Pakistan: Problems and Prospects” was the focus of all events. A special issue of PULSAA News was published in a book form, and entitled “A Treatise on Library and Information Science in Pakistan” (Qarshi 1993). PULSAA’s activities during the 1991–92 session included seminars, and two books were published. A conference was held in January 1993 (Javed 1993).

It would be unjust if I did not mention the role of the Netherlands Library Development Project in advancing the library profession in Pakistan. During the period studied, the NLDP worked on 108 different aspects of library development. Its activities in promoting information technology have already been described. Its other remarkable activities include strengthening library schools and professional associations; helping PLA in cooperative activities with organizations like IFLA, IDRC, UNESCO, USAID, the Asia Foundation, and the ALA; sending Pakistani librarians to short courses and orientation tours in the Netherlands; providing continuing education in technical services, library management, and preservation; promoting research in library and information science, and publishing library literature; preparing a directory of libraries; and revising curriculum (NLDP 1995 and Mushahid 1994).

Riazuddin (1991) commented on the overall situation of the profession in Pakistan by saying,

Librarianship in Pakistan, after facing numerous problems of money, manpower, material, and management, shows an upward trend. To conclude, the expansion of libraries, and the resulting growth of their resources and services, from cities down to villages... have widened the accessibility to libraries and books throughout the country. How this opportunity is utilized for further progress and betterment of the country will very much depend on our collective efforts to maximize their better use in the country.

Conclusion

The literature produced by Pakistani librarians during the 1990s presents an excellent picture of librarianship in the country. Although there is no effective mechanism for maintaining statistics on libraries in Pakistan, the literature cited suggests that the overall growth of libraries in the country is satisfactory. Remarkable achievements include the establishment and inauguration of the new National Library at Islamabad; the establishment of various university libraries in the private sector with large collections and many new services; the continuing support of the Punjab Library Foundation for public libraries; the trend towards the use of new information technology; and the revision of the library and information science curriculum to meet the emerging demands of the market. During the period studied, the Netherlands Library Development Project (NLDP) has boosted all professional activities. Its most significant work is the establishing of five computer training centres for librarians. Librarians also have started taking a more active part in professional associations. On the other hand, there are many deficiencies still to be overcome. Some efforts have been made to share resources, but this practice is generally ignored. No attention is paid to school libraries. There is a dire need for library education at the post–master’s level. Research activities in librarianship should be promoted by library schools and professional associations. Professional periodical literature should be published regularly. The lack of a national library and information policy is also a problem. The government should support and finance activities furthering library development in the country.

References

1. Akhtar 1992 — Abdul Hafeez Akhtar. “The Development of the National Library of Pakistan: A Country Report.” In 5th Conference of Directors of National Libraries of Asia and Oceania, 23–26 November 1992, pp. 1–7. Kuala Lumpur: Perpustakaan Negara Malaysia, 1992.

2. Akhtar 1993 — Abdul Hafeez Akhtar. “Introductory Remarks at the Opening Ceremony of the National Library of Pakistan, Islamabad, August 24, 1993.” Pakistan Library Bulletin 24 (December 1993): 5–9.

3. Anis 1987 — Anis Khurshid. “Library Development in Pakistan in the Mid–1980s.” International Library Review 18 (January 1987): 61–71.

4. Anis 1990 — Anis Khurshid. “Library Resources in Pakistan: Progress, Problems, and Achievements.” Third World Libraries 1–1 (Summer 1990): 10–21.
URL: http://ojsserv.dom.edu/ojs/index.php/worldlib/article/view/185/140

5. Anis 1992 — Anis Khurshid. “Library Education in Pakistan: Concerns, Issues and Practices.” In Library Education in Pakistan: Past, Present, and Future pp. 11–30. Edited by Sajjad ur Rehman, Abdus Sattar Chaudhry, and Afzal Haq Qarshi. Lahore: PULSAA, 1992.

6. Anis 1993 — Anis Khurshid. World Encyclopedia of Library and Information Services, 3rd ed. S.v. “Pakistan.” Chicago: American Library Association, 1993.

7. Anwar 1992 — Mumtaz A. Anwar. “Use of Information Technology in the Libraries of Pakistan.” Pakistan Library Association Journal 13 (August 1991–December 1992): 7–19.

8. Anwar 1993 — Mumtaz A. Anwar. “Founding of the National Library of Pakistan.” In Hallmarks of Library and Information Services in Pakistan, pp. 263–69. Edited by Muhammad Asghar, Afzal Haq Qarshi, and Syed Jamil Ahmad Rizvi. Lahore: PULSAA, 1993.

9. Aqila 1992 — Aqila Naz. “PLA NWFP Branch: Role in Strengthening the National Norms and Values of Pakistan Library Association.” Master’s thesis, University of Peshawar, 1992.

10. Basharat 1994 — Basharat Hafeez. “Library & Information Science Education in Pakistan through Distance Education System.” Master’s thesis, University of Peshawar, 1994.

11. Bushra 1990 — Bushra Almas Riaz. “LABELNET: Development of a Networking Project.” PULSAA News 2 (Summer 1990): 66–70.

12. Bushra 1993 — Bushra Almas Riaz. “Library Automation Problems in Pakistan.” In Challenges in Automating the Library Services pp. 27–34. Edited by Fida Mohammad. Peshawar: Department of Library & Information Science, University of Peshawar, 1993.

13. Bushra 1993a — Bushra Almas Riaz. “The PLA Computer Training Centre, Lahore: A New Era of Library and Information Science Education in Pakistan.” In Hallmarks of Library and Information Services in Pakistan, pp. 229–46. Edited by Muhammad Asghar, Afzal Haq Qarshi, and Syed Jamil Ahmad Rizvi. Lahore: PULSAA, 1993.

14. Fazil 1994 — Muhammad Fazil Khan. “Professional Development, Manpower Education and Training in Pakistan.” In World Encyclopedia of Library and Information Science Education, pp. 271–83. Edited by Paramjit Singh Kawatra. New Delhi: Crest Publishing House, 1994.

15. Fazil 1995 — Muhammad Fazil Khan. “University Education and Library Resources in Pakistan.” Pakistan Library Bulletin 26 (March 1995): 12–17.

16. Fazil 1996 — Muhammad Fazil Khan. “Resource Sharing and University Libraries in Pakistan.” Pakistan Library Association Journal 17 (October 1995 – March 1996): 45–52.

17. Haider 1995 — Syed Jalaluddin Haider. “Library Information Science Curriculum: A Futuristic Approach.” Pakistan Library Bulletin 26 (March 1995): i–ii.

18. Hamid 1992 — Hamid Rehman. “Demand and Supply of Library Science Graduates in Pakistan.” In Library Education in Pakistan: Past, Present and Future pp. 33–40. Edited by Sajjad ur Rehman, Abdus Sattar Chaudhry, and Afzal Haq Qarshi. Lahore: PULSAA, 1992.

19. Hanif 1990 — Akhtar Hanif. “Plan for Development of School, Children[’s] Libraries in Pakistan.” Pakistan Library Bulletin 21 (March 1990): 38–43.

20. Hanif 1991 — Akhtar Hanif. “Medical Librarianship in Pakistan.” Pakistan Library Bulletin 22 (December 1991): 1–2.

21. Jalal 1993 — Mohammad Ashraf Jalal. “Mobile Library Services in Pakistan.” In Hallmarks of Library and Information Services in Pakistan pp. 73–78. Edited by Muhammad Asghar, Afzal Haq Qarshi, and Syed Jamil Ahmad Rizvi. Lahore: PULSAA, 1993.

22. Javed 1993 — Ch. Javed Iqbal. “Staying on Top: PULSAA’s Struggle during 1991–92.” PULSAA News 5 (March 1993): 3–11.

23. Javed 1995 — Ch. Javed Iqbal. “The British Council Libraries: Librarianship with a Difference.” Pakistani Librarian 1 (1995): 13–16.

24. Javed and Meer 1990 — Ch. Javed Iqbal and M. Pervaiz Meer. “Agricultural Libraries in Pakistan: A Survey.” PULSAA News 2 (Summer 1990): 1–5.

25. Khalid 1995 — Khalid Mahmood. “Status of Library Automation in Pakistan.” Pakistan Library Bulletin 26 (March 1995): 18–26.

26. Khalid 1995a — Khalid Mahmood. “Library Software in Pakistan.” Information Development 11 (September 1995): 165–167.

27. Khalid 1996 — Khalid Mahmood. “Do You Need a Lamp to Enlighten Your Library? An Introduction to Library Automation and Management Program (LAMP).” INFOISIS 2 (March 1996): 7–16.

28. Khalid 1996a — Khalid Mahmood. “Promoting Information Technology in Pakistan: The Netherlands Library Development Project.” Information Development 12 (June 1996): 96–100.

29. Khalid 1996b — Khalid Mahmood. PLA Computer Training Centre, Lahore: Three Years of Success Lahore: The Centre, [1996].

30. Khalid 1996c — Khalid Mahmood. “Information Technology in Library Schools: A Case Study of the University of the Punjab.” Pakistan Library Association Journal 17 (October 1995 – March 1996): 7–15.

31. Khubaib 1996 — Hafiz Khubaib Ahmad, ed. Directory of Libraries in Pakistan. Islamabad: Pakistan Library Association, 1996.

32. Mangla 1994 — P. B. Mangla. “Library & Information Science Education in South Asia: India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Sri Lanka.” Education for Information 12 (December 1994): 399–427.

33. Maqsood 1993 — Maqsood Ahmed. “Library Automation: Survey of Computerized Library Services in Federal Area (Islamabad/Rawalpindi).” Pakistan Library Association, Federal Branch. News Bulletin 30–31 (June–December 1993): 76–77.

34. Mirza 1990 — Abdul Hamid Mirza. PULSAA Secretary’s Report 1989–1990 [Lahore: PULSAA, 1990.] lip.

35. Mushahid 1994 — Mushahid Hussain. “Effectiveness of NLDP’s Activities towards the Development of Library Profession in Pakistan.” Unpublished Master’s thesis, University of Balochistan, 1994.

36. Najaf 1995 — Najaf Ali Khan. “Information Technology in the University Libraries of Pakistan — Stresses and Strains.” Pakistan Library Bulletin 26(March 1995): 1–11.

37. Nasim 1990 — Nasim Fatima. “Standard of Children Libraries in Pakistan.” Pakistan Library Bulletin 21 (March 1990): 1–37.

38. Nasim 1991 — Nasim Fatima. “The Changing Concept of School Library and Pakistan.” Pakistan Library Bulletin 22 (September 1991): 1–9.

39. Nazir 1992 — Muhammad Nazir. “Library science batoar ikhtiari mazmoon: pas–e–manzar wa paish raft” [Library Science as Optional Subject: Background and Development]. PULSAA News 4 (January–June 1992): 8–10. In Urdu.

40. Niaz 1995 — Niaz Hussain. “Library Science Education through Allama Iqbal Open University.” Pakistan Journal of Distance Education 12 (1995): 37–53.

41. NLDP 1995 — Netherlands Library Development Project. –Netherlands Library Development Project Pakistan. Semi–Annual Progress Report no.8, Period January – August 1995 Islamabad: International Consultancies SOCRATES, September 1995.

42. Nuzhat 1990 — Nuzhat Yasmin. “National Information Network on Water Resources.” PULSAA News 2 (Summer 1990): 212–17.

43. Qarshi 1993 — Afzal Haq Qarshi. “Role of Associations other than PLA in the Development of Librarianship in Pakistan.” In Role of Professional Associations in Development of Librarianship in Pakistan: Proceedings of Seminar Held on October 21,1992, at the American Centre, Lahore pp. 17-29. Edited by Afzal Haq Qarshi and Ch. Javed Iqbal. Lahore: The American Centre.

44. Qureshi 1990 — Naimuddin Qureshi. “The Importance of Physical Facilities in University Libraries.” Pakistan Library Association Journal 9 (April 1990): 6–9.

45. Qureshi 1990a — Naimuddin Qureshi. “The Role of Medical College Libraries in Pakistan.” Pakistan Library Association Journal 10 (August 1990): 10–15.

46. Qureshi 1991 — Naimuddin Qureshi. “The Role of Professional Library Associations.” Pakistan Library Association Journal 12 (April 1991): 8–13.

47. Riazuddin 1991 — Syed Riazuddin. “Trends in the Development of Librarianship in Pakistan.” In Trends in International Librarianship: A Festschrift Honouring Anis Khurshid pp. 89–104. Edited by Naimuddin Qureshi and Zahiruddin Khurshid. Karachi: Royal Book Company, 1991.

48. Riazuddin 1993 — Syed Riazuddin. “Impact of Library Legislation in the Development of National Library of Pakistan.” In Impact of Library Legislation on the Development of Library Services in Pakistan: Proceedings of the PLA 14th Conference Held at Sheikh Zayed Islamic Centre, University of Karachi, from 7 to 9 March 1991 , pp. 292–302. Edited by Sadiq Ali Khan. Karachi: Pakistan Library Association, 1993.

49. Sadiq 1993 — Sadiq Ali Khan. “Public Libraries with Reference to Library Education and Automation.” In Challenges in Automating the Library Services, pp. 35–46. Edited by Fida Mohammad. Peshawar: Department of Library & Information Science, University of Peshawar 1993.

50. Sadiq 1994 — Sadiq Ali Khan. Educational Institutions and Library Development in Pakistan Karachi: Khurshid Nishan, 1994.

51. Sajjad 1992 — Sajjad ur Rehman. “Library Automation in Pakistan: Myths and Realities.” Pakistan Library Bulletin 23 (December 1992): 10–17.

52. Sajjad 1993 — Sajjad ur Rehman. “Development and Status of Library Education in Pakistan: A Review.” In Library and Information Services in Developing Countries: A Festschrift for Anis Khurshid pp. 22–34. Edited by Mumtaz A. Anwar, Abdus Sattar Chaudhry, and Mohammad Saleh J. Ashoor. Lahore: Library & Information Management Academy, 1993.

53. Sajjad 1994 — Sajjad ur Rehman. “Appraisal of Faculty Preparedness by Using Selected Variable.” Journal of Education for Library and Information Science 35 (Winter 1994): 20–30.

54. Samdani 1995 — Rais Ahmed Samdani. “Karachi kay kutub khanay aur PLA Computer Centre” [Libraries of Karachi and PLA Computer Centre]. Pakistan Library Bulletin 26 (March 1995): 1–8. In Urdu.

55. Shahnaz 1994 — Shahnaz Zuberi. “Revolution in Information Science: CD–ROM Technology in Pakistani Libraries.” Pakistan Library Association, Federal Branch. News Bulletin (January–December 1994): 54–61.

56. Shahnaz and Bhatti 1993 — Shahnaz Zuberi and Arshad R. Bhatti. “CD–ROM Technology in Pakistan.” LAG News 1(April–September 1993): 1–5.

57. Siddique 1992 — Muhammad Siddique. “Research in Library and Information Science in Pakistan.” Pakistan Library Association (Punjab). Quarterly Newsletter 3 (1992): 1–6.

58. Siddique 1994 — Muhammad Siddique. “Managing Punjab University Libraries on Scientific Principles.” PULSAA News 6 (September–December 1994): 3–5.

59. Siddiqui 1990 — Shehzad Ahmad Siddiqui. “USIS Libraries in Pakistan.” PULSAA News 2 (Summer 1990): 234–39.

60. Taj 1990 — Muhammad Taj. “State of Public Libraries and Their Services in Punjab.” PULSAA News 2 (Summer 1990): 17–30.

61. Umera 1993 — Umera Shah. “Role of Pakistan Library Association in Development of Librarianship in Pakistan.” In Role of Professional Associations in Development of Librarianship in Pakistan: Proceedings of Seminar held on October 21,1992, at the American Centre, Lahore pp. 9–16. Edited by Afzal Haq Qarshi and Ch. Javed Iqbal. Lahore: The American Centre, 1993.

62. Yaqub 1990 — Yaqub Ali Chaudhry. “University Libraries in Pakistan: A Profile.” PULSAA News 2(Summer 1990): 49–65.

63. Yaqub 1992 — Yaqub Ali Chaudhry. “Adaat–e–muttalia ka farogh bazaria jamiati kutub khana” [Promotion of Reading Habits through University Library]. Pakistan Library Association Journal 13 (August 1991–December 1992): 1–18. In Urdu.

About the author

Khalid Mahmood is Lecturer, Department of Library and Information Science, University of Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan.